T O P I C R E V I E W |
mm1983 | This question is in terms of selling here on MOTL only, not playing. Are Collector's Edition cards or world champion gold bordered cards considered to be proxy cards or not? |
psrex | quote: Originally posted by mm1983: This question is in terms of selling here on MOTL only, not playing. Are Collector's Edition cards or world champion gold bordered cards considered to be proxy cards or not?
Those are all real cards. If it's an official WoTC product then all is good. |
Volcanon | quote: Originally posted by mm1983: This question is in terms of selling here on MOTL only, not playing. Are Collector's Edition cards or world champion gold bordered cards considered to be proxy cards or not?
You can sell them here. But you have to say what they are. Don't say "Wasteland" and then send gold bordered cards. People will assume you're selling the tournament-legal cards. |
wayne | quote: Originally posted by mm1983: This question is in terms of selling here on MOTL only, not playing. Are Collector's Edition cards or world champion gold bordered cards considered to be proxy cards or not?
Depends on how you define proxy because those cards are not tournament legal.
|
mm1983 | I figured anything that was a WOTC official product was legal to sell or trade here on MOTL whether it is tournament legal or not. My next question is are the foil P9 cards a WOTC product or just something that someone made on their own to sell? |
nderdog | quote: Originally posted by wayne:
Depends on how you define proxy because those cards are not tournament legal.
For the purposes of being legal to trade/sell them on MOTL, it's anything that infringes on copyrights. Any product produced by WotC is fine. Gaming Etc. P9 are okay, as they were careful to avoid using names, artwork, mana symbols, etc. Most other proxies are not okay. __________________ There's no need to fear, UNDERDOG is here!All your Gruul Nodorogs are belong to me. Trade them to me, please! Report rules violations. Remember the Auctions Board!
|
Tha Gunslinga | quote: Originally posted by mm1983: My next question is are the foil P9 cards a WOTC product or just something that someone made on their own to sell?
Those are illegal copyright infringement and are not produced by Wizards. __________________ Looking for misprinted Commander decks. Got one? Talk to me.
|
djcards | quote: Originally posted by nderdog: Gaming Etc. P9 are okay, as they were careful to avoid using names, artwork, mana symbols, etc. Most other proxies are not okay. [/B]
quote: Originally posted by Tha Gunslinga: Those are illegal copyright infringement and are not produced by Wizards.
Did I miss something? Because this seems contradictory. |
Tha Gunslinga | The foil P9 that people make themselves have the following problems: Original art Original names Original textGamingetc proxies don't use any of those. __________________ Looking for misprinted Commander decks. Got one? Talk to me.
|